Magento Adobe Commerce VS BigCommerce – A Comprehensive Comparison
Versus
Magento vs BigCommerce — selecting the right eCommerce platform is crucial for business success, and it requires considering several key factors like scalability, customizability, and ease of use. Both Magento and BigCommerce are robust platforms, but they cater to different types of businesses and offer unique advantages.
Magento is highly regarded for its customizability and ability to support large, complex operations. It’s especially suited for enterprises with specific requirements that demand flexibility and control over every aspect of their online store. In contrast, BigCommerce is known for its out-of-the-box functionality and user-friendly setup, making it a great choice for small to medium-sized businesses looking for a comprehensive eCommerce solution without needing extensive development.
In this guide, we’ll explore how Magento vs BigCommerce stack up in terms of core features, ease of use, performance, and more, helping you make an informed decision for your business.
Magento/ Adobe Commerce vs BigCommerce – A 2024 Comparison Guide
Core Functionality and Features
When comparing Magento vs BigCommerce, both platforms offer robust solutions, but their feature sets target different types of businesses. Magento (Adobe Commerce) provides advanced, customizable features designed for enterprises with complex operations, while BigCommerce offers a more user-friendly, all-in-one solution tailored to businesses looking for simplicity without sacrificing power.
Magento
Magento is built for businesses that require extensive customizability and control over their operations. It offers advanced features like multi-store management, the ability to handle complex product catalogs, and powerful tools for B2B and B2C businesses. Magento is highly modular, allowing developers to build custom features or integrations to meet the specific needs of large enterprises.
From advanced inventory management to custom checkout flows, Magento gives businesses full control over their eCommerce experience, making it the platform of choice for companies with unique or complex requirements.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce, on the other hand, focuses on delivering robust out-of-the-box functionality. It comes with essential features like integrated payment gateways, shipping tools, and a built-in CMS, all of which make it easier for businesses to get started quickly without the need for heavy customization.
While BigCommerce doesn’t offer the same level of flexibility as Magento, it provides more than enough functionality for small to medium-sized businesses that need a reliable eCommerce platform with minimal setup and management. It’s an ideal choice for businesses that want a fast and efficient solution without the need for custom development.
Magento is perfect for businesses needing deep customization and advanced features, especially for complex B2B or multi-store operations. In contrast, BigCommerce offers robust features out of the box, making it a better fit for small to mid-sized businesses looking for ease of use and a quick setup.
Ease of Use and User Interface (UI)
In terms of ease of use, BigCommerce vs Magento shows clear differences. BigCommerce is known for its intuitive interface and ease of setup, making it a great choice for businesses without technical expertise. Magento, on the other hand, offers deep customization and flexibility but requires more technical knowledge or developer support to manage effectively.
Magento
When it comes to ease of use, Magento is more powerful but requires technical expertise to fully utilize its features. Magento Open Source provides complete flexibility and control over the store, but this means a steep learning curve. Setting up and managing a Magento store often requires the involvement of developers, especially when dealing with complex operations like multi-store management or integrating custom extensions.
Adobe Commerce does simplify some processes, but overall, Magento is a platform suited for businesses that can afford to dedicate resources to technical management.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce, on the other hand, is widely recognized for its user-friendly drag-and-drop interface. It allows businesses to easily customize their online store without needing coding skills. From the dashboard, users can manage everything from product listings to order fulfillment and shipping options. T
he BigCommerce control panel simplifies tasks like adding new products, configuring shipping rules, and managing payments. This makes BigCommerce an attractive option for small to medium-sized businesses or those without dedicated development teams.
Magento offers unmatched flexibility and customization but comes with a higher level of complexity that requires technical expertise. BigCommerce excels in ease of use, making it a more suitable choice for businesses looking for a straightforward, non-technical solution.
Performance and Scalability
When looking at performance and scalability in Magento vs BigCommerce, Magento shines with its ability to handle complex, high-traffic eCommerce operations, offering scalability for global enterprises. BigCommerce also offers strong scalability but is more suited for businesses seeking a balance between ease of use and growth potential, making it ideal for mid-market stores aiming to scale.
Magento
Magento is built with scalability in mind, making it the ideal choice for large businesses or enterprises with complex needs. Because Magento is a self-hosted platform, businesses have full control over server performance and optimization. This allows for fine-tuning aspects like caching, CDNs, and database management to ensure that stores perform well even under heavy traffic loads.
Magento’s architecture is designed to handle large product catalogs, complex pricing structures, and high-traffic environments. This makes it an excellent option for businesses that plan to scale significantly or operate in multiple regions with different storefronts.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce, while also scalable, handles performance and scaling on its own servers as a hosted solution. This removes the burden of manual optimization from the business’s side, making it easier to manage for those who don’t want to deal with the complexities of server performance.
BigCommerce offers features like automatic scaling, load balancing, and a global CDN to ensure that stores remain fast and responsive even as they grow. However, larger enterprises may find that they need more control over their infrastructure, something that Magento is better suited for.
Magento provides full control over performance and scalability, making it ideal for large businesses with specific needs. BigCommerce offers simplified, managed scalability that works well for small to medium-sized businesses, but may not provide the level of control that some enterprises require.
Customization and Flexibility
The Magento vs BigCommerce comparison is especially striking when it comes to customization. Magento provides unparalleled customization through its open-source platform, allowing businesses to modify every aspect of their store. BigCommerce, while not open-source, still offers robust customization options, but users are more limited in terms of backend flexibility compared to Magento.
Magento
Magento is known for its unparalleled customization options. Being an open-source platform, it allows businesses to modify the core code, create custom modules, and integrate third-party applications or extensions. This makes it ideal for businesses that need to tailor every aspect of their eCommerce store to meet specific requirements. With Magento, companies have complete control over their site’s appearance, functionality, and backend processes.
Developers can create unique workflows, custom checkout processes, and integrations with external systems like ERP or CRM solutions. However, this level of customization requires technical expertise and developer resources to implement and maintain.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce also offers customization options, though it’s more limited compared to Magento. As a SaaS (Software as a Service) platform, users can customize their store’s appearance using pre-designed themes or by modifying the HTML and CSS. BigCommerce also provides an open API, allowing for integrations with third-party services and apps. However, it lacks the deep backend customization that Magento provides, meaning businesses are more constrained by what the platform allows.
While this is ideal for businesses looking for quick, low-maintenance setups, those requiring significant flexibility may find BigCommerce’s options limited.
Magento is the go-to platform for businesses needing complete customization and control over their eCommerce environment, while BigCommerce provides solid customization options but remains limited by its SaaS model, making it more suitable for businesses looking for simplicity over deep customization.
Pricing and Total Cost of Ownership
When comparing Magento vs BigCommerce, it’s essential to evaluate both the initial setup costs and the total cost of ownership (TCO) over time.
Magento
While Magento’s open-source version is free, running a Magento store requires significant investments in hosting, development, and maintenance. For businesses opting for Magento Commerce (Adobe Commerce Development), costs can rise steeply, with licensing fees starting at approximately $20,000 per year. On top of this, businesses will need to factor in costs for custom development, premium extensions, and advanced hosting solutions to ensure the platform performs optimally.
Due to the platform’s resource-intensive nature, robust infrastructure is required, which can also drive up costs. Magento is best suited for businesses that have the budget to invest in a highly customizable, scalable platform
BigCommerce
BigCommerce, on the other hand, provides a more transparent pricing model, with plans starting at $29.95 per month and scaling up based on business size and features needed. BigCommerce includes hosting, security, and regular updates in its pricing, making it easier for businesses to predict costs.
While there are higher-priced plans for larger businesses, such as the Enterprise tier, BigCommerce’s overall cost of ownership is typically lower than Magento’s, especially for small to medium-sized businesses that don’t need extensive customization or control.
Magento offers more flexibility and advanced features but comes with higher long-term costs due to hosting, development, and maintenance. BigCommerce provides a more affordable, all-inclusive pricing model that’s easier to manage for small to medium-sized businesses.
Security and Compliance
In terms of security, Magento and BigCommerce both offer strong security features, but Magento provides more control over specific security settings and updates. BigCommerce, being a fully hosted platform, includes automatic security updates and PCI compliance, making it an attractive option for businesses that prefer not to manage security manually.
Magento
Magento provides advanced security options but leaves the responsibility for managing updates and patches to the business. This can be both an advantage and a challenge, as it allows for deep control but requires dedicated resources to maintain. PCI compliance, data encryption, and regular security patches are crucial components of Magento’s security features, but businesses need to stay proactive about applying patches and managing security protocols.
For enterprises with specific compliance needs or those handling sensitive customer data, Magento’s flexibility allows for custom security configurations, but it’s necessary to have a team or partner like Atwix to manage it.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce, on the other hand, takes a more hands-off approach for businesses by managing all security patches, PCI compliance, and SSL certificates automatically. This makes BigCommerce an ideal choice for companies that prefer not to deal with the technical aspects of security.
BigCommerce’s hosting is fully PCI Level 1 compliant, and the platform manages the ongoing security updates, offering a more streamlined approach to data protection and compliance, making it easier for small and mid-sized businesses to stay secure without added technical burden.
Magento provides more control over security but requires businesses to handle updates and compliance themselves, while BigCommerce simplifies security management by taking care of updates and compliance automatically.
Customer Support
Both Magento and BigCommerce offer extensive support options, but the level of support you receive depends on the version of the platform you are using and the resources available through the community.
Magento
Magento users benefit from a large, active community and extensive documentation, including forums, guides, and tutorials. For businesses using Magento Commerce (Adobe Commerce), there is access to dedicated support that includes technical assistance, security updates, and priority support channels.
This is particularly beneficial for enterprises that require professional help in managing complex eCommerce setups. For open-source users, community support is readily available, but resolving complex issues may require hiring a certified Magento developer
BigCommerce
BigCommerce offers 24/7 support across all its pricing tiers, providing assistance through live chat, phone, and email. Additionally, BigCommerce maintains a robust knowledge base with articles, guides, and tutorials for users.
Enterprise-level customers receive even more specialized support, including dedicated account managers and advanced technical assistance, ensuring that businesses have the help they need to scale effectively.
Magento provides community support for Open Source users and premium support for Adobe Commerce clients, while BigCommerce offers 24/7 support for all users, with enhanced services for enterprise customers.
SEO Capabilities
For businesses focused on driving organic traffic, SEO capabilities are crucial when choosing an eCommerce platform. Both Magento and BigCommerce offer strong SEO tools, but Magento provides more advanced options for complex SEO strategies.
Magento
Magento is known for its advanced SEO capabilities. The platform allows users to customize URLs, meta tags, and sitemaps, making it easier for businesses to implement complex SEO strategies. Magento’s ability to integrate with third-party SEO tools and extensions gives businesses more control over how they optimize their site for search engines.
For businesses that need detailed and specific SEO configurations, Magento’s flexibility is a huge advantage. However, it requires a knowledgeable team to set up and manage SEO properly.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce also offers a strong set of built-in SEO tools, including customizable URLs, auto-generated sitemaps, and the ability to edit meta descriptions and titles easily. It’s designed to be user-friendly, making it easy for businesses to optimize their site without needing extensive technical knowledge.
While BigCommerce’s SEO tools are sufficient for most small to medium-sized businesses, they may not offer the same depth and control that Magento provides for companies with more advanced SEO strategies.
Magento offers more advanced SEO tools and integrations, making it ideal for businesses with complex SEO strategies while BigCommerce provides solid SEO capabilities out of the box, offering a more user-friendly approach for businesses with simpler SEO needs.
Magento vs BigCommerce: A Final Side-by-Side Comparison
When comparing Magento and BigCommerce, it becomes clear that both platforms have their strengths, depending on the business’s size, technical resources, and long-term goals. Below is a comparison table to help visualize the key differences.
| Feature | Magento | BigCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Core Functionality | Highly customizable with advanced features like multi-store management, complex product catalogs, and B2B tools | Out-of-the-box functionality with integrated CMS, payment gateways, and shipping tools |
| Ease of Use | Steeper learning curve, requires technical expertise for setup and management | Easy-to-use, drag-and-drop interface suitable for non-technical users |
| Performance & Scalability | Self-hosted solution offering full control over performance, ideal for large enterprises | Hosted solution with automatic scaling, great for small to medium-sized businesses |
| Customization | Unlimited customization through open-source architecture and custom modules | Limited customization through apps and APIs, controlled by SaaS platform |
| Pricing | Free Open Source, with hosting and development costs; Adobe Commerce starts at $22,000/year | Transparent pricing starting at $29.95/month, includes hosting, security, and updates |
| Security | Advanced security, but users must manage updates and PCI compliance | Hands-off security management, automatic patches, PCI compliance built-in |
| SEO Capabilities | Advanced SEO tools with full customization and third-party integration | Built-in SEO tools sufficient for small to mid-sized businesses, but with fewer options for advanced users |
| Customer Support | Community-driven support for Open Source; premium support for Adobe Commerce users | 24/7 support through chat, email, and phone for all users, with additional enterprise services |
Summary
When choosing between Magento and BigCommerce, the right platform depends largely on your business’s size, complexity, and long-term goals.
- Magento is the superior choice for large enterprises or businesses that need complete control over their eCommerce operations. Its unparalleled customization options and scalability make it ideal for companies with complex needs, but it comes with a steeper learning curve and higher total cost of ownership.
- BigCommerce, on the other hand, is a better fit for small to medium-sized businesses looking for an easy-to-use, all-in-one solution. It provides robust functionality out of the box, along with automatic security and hosting, making it a simpler and more affordable option for businesses that don’t require deep customization or technical management.
At Atwix, as certified partners agency for both Magento and BigCommerce, we have the expertise to help you select and implement the best platform for your business. Whether you need a powerful, customizable Magento store or an efficient BigCommerce setup, our team is here to guide you through every step.
Frequently Asked Questions
Got some questions? We’re here to answer. If you don’t see your question here, drop us a line with out Contact form.
How easy is it to migrate from BigCommerce to Magento?
Migrating from BigCommerce to Magento can be done using migration tools and services. However, the process may require technical expertise to ensure a smooth transfer of data, including product catalogs, customer information, and order histories. Working with a development team or partner like Atwix can simplify this process and ensure that all aspects of the store are successfully migrated.
Is Magento or BigCommerce better for large enterprises?
Magento is better suited for large enterprises that require extensive customizability, scalability, and control over their online store operations. Its open-source nature allows for advanced features and complex setups, making it ideal for businesses with unique needs. BigCommerce, while scalable, is better suited for mid-market businesses that need a robust, managed solution without the need for deep customization.
Which platform provides better SEO tools, Magento or BigCommerce?
Magento provides more advanced SEO capabilities, allowing users to fully customize URLs, meta tags, and integrate third-party SEO extensions. It’s ideal for businesses with complex SEO strategies. BigCommerce offers solid built-in SEO tools that are easier to use but don’t offer the same depth of control as Magento.
What are the long-term costs associated with running Magento compared to BigCommerce?
While Magento Open Source is free, businesses need to account for hosting, development, and security management costs. Adobe Commerce starts at $22,000 annually, making it a significant investment for large businesses. BigCommerce offers a more predictable pricing model, starting at $29.95 per month, which includes hosting and security. For smaller businesses, BigCommerce tends to have lower long-term costs.
Is BigCommerce a good option for B2B businesses, or is Magento better suited for that?
While BigCommerce does offer B2B features like customer-specific pricing and bulk order management, Magento is generally better suited for B2B businesses that require advanced tools such as multi-store management, custom workflows, and in-depth integrations with third-party systems like ERPs or CRMs.
Which How secure is BigCommerce compared to Magento in terms of data protection?
BigCommerce manages all security patches and updates automatically, making it easy for businesses to stay PCI compliant and secure. Magento, on the other hand, gives users full control over their security measures, but this requires regular management of patches and compliance protocols. For businesses that need more flexibility in security, Magento is a better option, though it requires more hands-on effort.
